December blues began to pour into our conversations, leaving us hungover for days on end. we slept through the mornings and well into the afternoons on an unmade bed fit for two. our bodies were nothing more than skin and bones that crisscrossed at odd angles on eggshell-colored sheets and pillows. we had stayed indoors so much the past few weeks — a trait of our similar introverted natures as well an unspoken hunger between us to spend as much time together as we possibly could away from everyone else — that our skin had lost both color and vibrancy. when we would finally awake late in the afternoon, and look at ourselves in the bathroom mirror, we would find dark violet-grey crescent moons buried beneath our eyes. in turn, Robert would splash water on his face and i would rub a baby blue gel-cream onto my skin, hoping that the crescents would disappear; i much preferred them shining bright in the sky than hanging on my face.
as the december days hid — and in their place the december nights entered through the cracked-open slit in our kitchen window — we were overcome with a hunger to be more than we were, a yearning for a different stroke of life.
fall had been odd, peculiar, unmanageable, and unimaginable: Robert struggled with his work while i fought with all the versions of myself that no longer served me any purpose. i had to let go of them, but i was incapable; i hated change, even if it was good for me.
our relationship also had its ups and downs during this time. we found ourselves deeply in love one day, then silent friends the next. we went from spending all day together in bed, listening to records and talking about a vastitude of topics — from poetry to film to our upstairs neighbor’s weird insistence that we were siblings because we looked so much alike — to spending several days in succession without speaking more than a few words to one another. and though this behavior could be seen as normal, for partners are not always attached at the hip, i suppose it was the way that we oscillated between matching our language, both body and mind, to one another’s to then hardly speaking at all that left me constantly feeling displaced in our relationship.
but even in silence and stillness, there was still a magnetism between us that existed far beyond the physical. the waning embers of our love glowed all around us, that i knew — and Robert did, too; we just never said anything about them. and on the days where we existed apart from one another, i held onto those embers a a little bit tighter. i had always been fiercely independent and counter-dependent, but with Robert, i couldn’t help myself from becoming more and more codependent, hungry for even the tiniest morsel of his approval, validation, and love.
i was used to this rollercoaster of emotions, and i had learned long ago how to exist in this grey space (and even thrive in it), but i found it especially difficult to deal with this time around because of how much i adored Robert. i was torn between myself — who i was, who i had created myself to be in order to stay safe, and who i was becoming — and how i felt for Robert and what we had created together. my love had always been warm, generous, and giving, but over the years, i had learned how to quell it to be lukewarm at best. i had met far too many people who hadn’t deserved my love and affection, so i taught myself how to shut it down and how to keep any feelings i had for anyone to a minimum, if at all. yet, and despite all of my attempts to squash it, deep down inside of me there still burned a love so bright and so unforgiving that it was waiting to be let out. i wanted to share it with Robert, but i couldn’t tell if he wanted this love of mine. i also could never tell if Robert knew how much i cared for him to begin with because i was so cautious with my love. by all accounts, he seemed happy with our arrangement, so that became good enough for me, most of the time at least.
however, when we had lulls in our relationship, i grew antsy and anxious. fearing that i had done something to drive him away, i felt a compulsive need to get his attention without outwardly saying so. the logical thing to do was to have a conversation with him, to share my worries and fears, but my anxieties always triumphed logic; that, and i was conflict-avoidant. i had no interest in honest conversations. honest conversations always carried risks with them and one of those risks was physical altercation. i had experienced it before and i had enough physical scars to prove it. i also had no masochistic streak in my body to explore that part of my life again, so honest conversations were off the table.
but Robert was different and i knew that. i felt that. he was kind, he never raised his voice, and his touch warmed my body. he made me feel safe in a way that no one ever had. yet, a part of me still worried that maybe i hadn’t read him right, that maybe one day he would snap, hit me, and push me up against a wall, threatening to hurt me in ways that i couldn’t even imagine. i recognized that he wasn’t capable of doing such a thing, but what if he was? what if he was?
i resented myself for thinking so poorly of him, but could you blame me? it was my brain’s evolutionary protection mechanism kicking in. i just wanted to be safe. and if being safe meant keeping my mouth shut, while doing everything to get him to notice me on his own accord, then so be it. old habits die hard.
one evening in mid-November, while Robert read a book in the kitchen and enjoyed a glass of whiskey, i snuck into our bathroom to cut my hair and dye it blonde. a part of me grew tired of staring at the same person in the mirror, and another part of me wanted Robert’s attention in any way that i could get it. once i was done, i sheepishly entered the kitchen and waited for him to take notice. i expected Robert to get mad (for every reason already stated, but more so, in that moment, because of a pronounced side-effect of dating a string of physically and emotionally abusive men before him), but he didn’t. instead, he looked at me with his big brown eyes and smiled from ear-to-ear with his signature childlike grin.
“you look electric,” he said and immediately dropped his book onto the table. he walked over to me and i counted every step. when he began to run his fingers through my hair, i held my breath. i watched the way he marveled at me, like i was a piece of art only he had access to. he scratched at my temples and tugged on my hair, feeling its new, choppy texture in between his fingers. i closed my eyes and faded away into the sensation of his touch. his fingers moved down to my cheeks and then down to my jawline until he had his index finger resting underneath my chin. he raised it ever-so-slightly to get my attention. i opened my eyes and met his.
“why are you running from me?” he asked, his voice tender and full of concern. Robert had this inexplicable ability to melt time and space and unravel you in ways that you didn’t think were possible. i had always been the person strangers told their secrets to, yet the first time i met Robert, i found myself sharing secrets i thought i would never tell a soul. he didn’t ask the question again out loud, but i heard it again once more: “why are you running from me?”. i suddenly felt an overwhelming urge to both cry and collapse in his arms. i was so tired of running, but if i stopped, who would i be? would he be able to handle that version of me? no one had been able to handle me in any version of me before this so why should this time be any different?
“hey.”
his voice cut through the sandstorm of thoughts swirling in my head. almost as if he was reading my mind, and it often felt like he was, he said “i’m not going anywhere” and dragged his thumb slowly across my lips before leaning in to kiss them. every kiss with Robert felt like the first and the last: the first because it always felt gentle, new, and innocent, and the last because i always feared that he would realize he wasn’t really in love with me but some idea of me that i had let him think existed.
i leaned into his embrace and wrapped my arms around his body. i could run away another time, this i reasoned with myself, but for now, i really wanted to stop running — and, for long enough to enjoy this moment and him and us before i felt that urge to start running kick in again.